Astringent vs Toner

Most people have no idea what the difference is between astringent vs toner. If you’re slightly confused or scratching your head without a clue, then you’ve come to the right place. However, most people simply don’t care to understand the difference between these two skin care products. They put zero effort into even acknowledging what ingredients are in the products that they are using. Since you’re here, I’m assuming that you are not like most people. You actually care about this type of thing and what you put into your body. For that, I commend you and I’m going to do my best to help teach you a thing or two today.

In the event that you need to make a decision, astringent vs toner, and you’re not sure which to go with, I want you to hold off for now. Don’t make any purchasing decisions until you’ve read this entire page and are more informed. You’ll soon know which is better to incorporate into your personal skin care routine.

However, before you determine which is best, you need to know more about each type of product. I’m not talking about just the benefits. You need to familiarize yourself with the drawbacks of using each as well. Once you know what both an astringent and toner do for your skin, only then care you make a well-thought decision as to which is best for your skin type and personal routine. There are a lot of factors involved. Let’s dive right into things!

astringent vs tonerAstringent vs Toner And The Ingredients Involved

This may sound pretty basic but the main differentiating factor between any astringent vs toner is simply the ingredients contained. I know, it’s pretty obvious that this is the case but some people don’t understand that. Let me start by talking about toners. Most skin toners contain¬†either glycol or glycerine.

These ingredients are used to help balance out the PH levels of your skin. They also help soothe and make your skin feel nice and smooth. It’s not uncommon for women to purchase toners that are water-based. Most of these water-based toners include great ingredients that really improve your skin. Ingredients such as antioxidants and niacinamide (also know as vitamin B). Manufacturers formulate toner products with these to help repair damaged skin cells.

As for astringents, they are not water-based. Most of the astringents are alcohol-based which can really do a number on your skin’s hydration. These can dry out your skin purposefully, in order to help reduce or even remove oil from your skin. In most cases, the astringent is typically rubbing alcohol or a more natural form of alcohol that’s less invasive on the skin.

The way that these products avoid excessive drying of the skin is to use witch hazel in the formula instead of alcohol. With hazel is the primary ingredient in some brands of astringents, it is safer to use and less damaging for those that might have sensitive skin. The good news for people using an astringent that contains alcohol is that they are also able to fight bacteria and acne breakouts due to alcohol’s antibacterial powers.

Now that we’ve covered the ingredients in astringents vs toners, it is now time to assess which type of product is best for which type of skin. I’ll be covering each skin type now to help you make better purchasing decisions based on your personal skin type.

Dry Skin

If you have really dry skin, then you’re going to want to avoid using an astringent. Alcohol content contained in astringents can further dry out your skin. Since the primary purpose of using this product is to remove oil from your skin, you have no need to use it. You’ve got another problem on your hands, dry skin.

What I recommend is that you avoid the alcohol altogether. Instead, go with a water-based skin toner. If you can find one for extra sensitive skin then even better. Using the toner should help you keep the redness, inflammation, and dryness down. Your skin will feel better hydrated if you use a toner versus an astringent.

Oily Skin

If your one of the millions that battle with excess oil on their skin, then you might want to pick up that bottle of astringent solution. Reason being, the astringent can help fight off the bacteria that can often be present in people with oily skin. Given that bacteria causes acne, it can also help fight acne. Incorporating an astringent into your routine will help clean your pores and attack the nasty blackheads and pimples on your skin. Pick up the astringent and put down the toner!

Sensitive Skin

If you have sensitive skin then your best bet is to avoid using astringents or anything alcohol-based. It’s too harsh on your skin and will likely cause more harm than good. Stick with a product that uses witch hazel as the main ingredient. It’s going to cause less irritation but you are not completely in the clear with this. Now, if you are torn between using an astringent versus a toner, then the choice is simple. Start with the toner and see how your skin reacts to it. Don’t jump the gun and go straight for the harsh stuff. That’s a very bad idea.


Sure, some people have problem areas on their face where certain areas seem to be oily while other areas are dry, it happens. In the event that this is you, then your best bet would be to avoid any alcohol-based astringents and instead pick up the witch hazel. This will help you better regulate your skin.

How To Use These Products

When it comes to product use, you’re going to want to be very careful when using an astringent. It’s possible to cause more damage to your skin if you decide to use too much astringent in your daily skin routine. In fact, it can be counter-intuitive if you have oily skin. Meaning, your skin will start to produce even more oil than necessary. This is your skins way of protecting itself from harm.

As for the toners, they won’t do as much harm to your skin if you choose to use them more than necessary. What I personally recommend is that you first do your best to try out each product in small amounts. See how your skin reacts to the products and then take things further based on the results you get. Proper skin care is not a race, it’s a lifestyle. Keep that in mind when you’re looking for your next quick fix. Whatever you do, don’t use anything in excess!

Astringent vs Toner
Rate this post